Robert Kowal

 Words Sounds Wine

The Ear Directs the Eye

I find my self today on the shores of Lake Quin­ault. The two dozen writ­ers con­vened here dis­play an intrigu­ing range of coun­te­nances (and no doubt tal­ent – but I have no basis for com­men­tary), but in this serene and pre­his­tor­i­cally quiet set­ting, I was hop­ing to encounter voices. I must be patient, for it takes days to habit­u­ate to one’s sonic envi­ron­ment, to hear anew.

We are scopocen­tric crea­tures and we live in a cul­ture where the image is supreme but hear­ing is our pri­mary sense. Being omni­di­rec­tional and bin­au­ral, our ears ori­ent and locate us. Our eyes may indi­cate a des­ti­na­tion or fix the object of our desire but our ears inform us of where we are. This is often impos­si­ble to appre­ci­ate in the mod­ern world because our envi­ron­ment is sat­u­rated with irrel­e­vant and unwanted sound – noise. It is inescapable. As nat­u­ral­ist writer Bill McK­ibben and audio ecol­o­gist Gor­don Hemp­ton[1] have writ­ten, the nat­ural world no longer exists because there is no place (per­haps a hand­ful if one is gen­er­ous) human activ­ity, man-made noise, or our envi­ron­men­tal dis­rup­tion has not penetrated.

Con­sider then our domes­tic envi­ron­ment; hum­ming refrig­er­a­tor com­pres­sors, whirling com­puter fans, rum­bling fur­naces, dron­ing air con­di­tion­ers, and scream­ing flu­o­res­cent fix­tures inun­dates us. These are but the pas­sive noises of our home. To this we vol­un­tar­ily add the blar­ing chat­ter of the tele­vi­sion or the sedat­ing acoustic salve of banal back­ground music. From the exte­rior intrudes the end­less ebb and flow of traf­fic noise whether it be deliv­ery trucks tak­ing a short­cut down your street or the roar­ing white noise of the Inter­state a few miles off.

We can close our eyes but our ears, being pri­mary, are always on duty. They con­stantly col­lect the spu­ri­ous sounds of our world which our brains must process and then dis­card; an evo­lu­tion­ary relic of the days when we had to worry about preda­tors rustling in the nearby brush. But this chore takes its toll. Our minds spend con­sid­er­able energy in the work of sort­ing the noise from the few gen­uine sig­nals in our mod­ern environment.

On the rare occa­sions when one can find a truly quiet place, the ear and the mind slowly read­just. By ‘quiet’ I do not mean the silence of an ana­choic cham­ber or a sound­proof room; no, so long as one is alive there is sound. Find a spot quiet enough and one can hear the var­i­ous trick­les and groans of the gas­troin­testi­nal tract, the grind­ing fric­tion of bone against car­ti­lage as one moves, the rush of blood through one’s cir­cu­la­tory extrem­i­ties, the click of your eye­lids, the beat­ing of your own heart. Absolute dark­ness, though unusual, can be found in caves and other nat­ural set­tings, but there is no absolute silence. Thus quiet is not the absence of sound, it is the absence of noise. It is the “heal­ing silence” cited fre­quently by Thomas Merton; a location/condition where intro­spec­tion and con­tem­pla­tion are pos­si­ble.[2]

Tomor­row, I plan to visit the One Square Inch of Silence in the Hoh National For­est.Visit OSIOS.org I have been for­tu­nate enough to visit a few quiet places in my life – the inte­rior high­lands of Ice­land, the Kalau­papa penin­sula of Molokai – and on each occa­sion I found that, with suf­fi­cient time, my appre­ci­a­tion of the human voice reemerged. I could hear again the mel­liflu­ous musi­cal­ity of speech; the par­tic­u­lar­i­ties of tone and the com­plex rhythms of con­ver­sa­tion. I could again rel­ish the exquis­ite per­son­al­ity of gen­uine laugh­ter, as indi­vid­ual as our fin­ger­prints. All of this we miss in the noisy world, or rather; we for­sake it in favor of our con­ve­nient devices and addic­tive dis­trac­tions. I hope to reclaim a frag­ment of this tomor­row to carry with me back to my noisy home, per­haps to sus­tain me for some span.

  1. [1] Bill McK­ibben The End of Nature, Gor­don Hempton’s One Square Inch of Silence
  2. [2] Keep your eyes clean and your ears quiet and your mind serene. Breathe God’s air. Work, if you can, under His sky.
    But if you have to live in a city and work among the machines and ride the sub­ways and eat in place where the radio makes you deaf with spu­ri­ous news and where the food destroys your life and the sen­ti­ments of those around you poi­son your heart with bore­dom, do not be upset, but accept it as the love of God and as the seed of soli­tude planted in your soul, and be glad of this suf­fer­ing: for it will keep you alive to the next oppor­tu­nity to escape from them and be alone in the heal­ing silence of rec­ol­lec­tions and in the untrou­bled pres­ence of God.

    Thomas Mer­ton, New Seeds of Con­tem­pla­tion, 1961

This entry was posted on Thursday, March 10th, 2011 at 1:40 pm and is filed under BLOG . You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

There is 7 comments to this post.
  1. momk Says:

    What a beau­ti­ful rumi­na­tion. Thank you!!!


  2. Mary Robinette Kowal Says:

    While dis­agree­ing with your premise that the ear is pri­mary for every­one, I do agree that the inabil­ity to shut one’s ears causes a fatigue that one can avoid with the eyes.


  3. -e- Says:

    A plea­sure to read and think about. The house seemed quiet, but this post got me attuned to the paper sound of Rebecca turn­ing pages in the next room, and the gur­gle of Ben’s fish tank, and (no kid­ding) the lone­some whis­tle of a far off train…


  4. Sandra M. Odell Says:

    I agree with Mary that the ear may not be pri­mary for every­one, but the need for quiet is a pow­er­ful, dri­ving force.

    Thank you for your post. And thank you, Mary, for direct­ing me here.


  5. Todd Moody Says:

    Well done, Robert! I have tin­ni­tus, so when I am for­tu­nate enough to find the quiet place it gets very loud for me. White noise is my sal­va­tion. I hope you are enjoy­ing your time in the Rainforest!


  6. Rob Says:

    To clar­ify: by ‘pri­mary’, I do not mean that hear­ing is more impor­tant than vision, but that it is our sense of first alert. One hears the snap and our ears direct the eyes where to look in response. It is the one sense which is actu­ally more acute when we sleep for the same rea­son; it is our first and most con­sis­tent sen­sory con­nec­tion to our envi­ron­ment. One a more per­sonal level, I would rather loose my sight than my hear­ing; I grant that the loss of sight may be a greater func­tional hand­i­cap but to be deaf is to be com­pletely alone.


  7. Rob Says:

    Good day,

    I too have suf­fered from tin­ni­tus but only spo­rad­i­cally and for brief inter­vals. As is the case for many, the cause is uncer­tain. Per­sum­ing you do not have per­ma­nent dam­age from high vol­ume expo­sure, it may be some­thing as sim­ple as diet. But as I menioned, this dis­or­der is not well understood.

    The Hoh rain for­est is a won­drous place. I may blog about the day at some point but for now I want to rel­ish is per­son­ally. I would how­ever encour­age any­one with the oppor­tu­nity to visit the Hoh or any of the park trail in Olympic National Park. Thank you for your comments.


Leave a Reply

Menu
Links
  • City Winery
  • Frameworks Wine
  • LazyTown
  • Willamette Radio Workshop